Editorial Advisory Committee - American Camp Association

Manuscript Evaluation Sheet

Your Name

Your E-mail

Name of Manuscript

1. Is the manuscript worthy of publication?

Yes
No

2. If you answered "No" to #1, could this manuscript be accepted for publication …

	…with a minor revision?
	…with a major revision?

3. If you think the article needs major revisions, please explain what and why (open ended question)

4. Is the content of the manuscript relevant to the camp industry and applicable to our readership?

Yes
No
Somewhat

5. Does the content of this manuscript represent a current, emerging, or "best" camp program, practice, or concept that will benefit our readership?

Yes
No
Somewhat

6. Is the manuscript interesting and readable?

Yes
No
Somewhat

7. Please use this space to provide comments to any of the questions above. (open-ended question)

Contact ACA